Arab Press

بالشعب و للشعب
Wednesday, Dec 11, 2024

UK minister mulling law change to define sex as ‘biological’

UK minister mulling law change to define sex as ‘biological’

Kemi Badenoch told definition change could provide ‘greater legal clarity.’
Britain's equalities minister is mulling a change to the law that would only allow women access to some same-sex spaces and sporting arenas on the basis of so-called "biological" grounds.

Kemi Badenoch has been told that defining someone's sex as "biological" could provide "greater legal clarity" on issues such as who accesses women-only hospital wards, and who can participate in certain sporting events.

But it would also be "more ambiguous or potentially disadvantageous" in areas such as equal pay and sex discrimination.

The advice came in a letter from Kishwer Falkner, chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC). Badenoch wrote to the commission in February requesting guidance on the "benefits or otherwise" of amending the definition of sex in the existing Equality Act.

Falkner notes that under the Gender Recognition Act of 2004, "a person with a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) becomes the acquired gender ‘for all purposes’ and recognised as their legal sex, broadly equivalent to the way sex recorded at birth is recognised in law for other people."

But she argues this may result in some legal uncertainties.

Under current laws, Falkner wrote, providers of women-only services such as hospital wards have to "conduct a careful balancing exercise to justify excluding all trans women."

"A biological definition of sex would make it simpler to make a women’s-only ward a space for biological women," she said.

Transgender rights advocates and many experts argue, however, that strict definitions of sex based on anatomy at birth can miss biological nuances.

In sports, organizers currently have to show that excluding transgender women is necessary "in the interests of fairness or safety." Defining sex as "biological" would remove that "additional burden," Falkner said.

But "detailed policy and legal analysis" should be undertaken if the government wanted to pursue a change, Falkner warned.

The Scottish parliament earlier this year passed a bill that seeks to make it easier for people to legally change their gender, prompting the U.K. government to claim it goes against the U.K.-wide Equality Act.

LGBTQ+ charity Stonewall told PinkNews the EHRC’s response “fails to recognise that the Equality Act 2010 has successfully supported businesses and service providers to challenge discrimination.”

“We would expect the EHRC to make further reference to some of the challenges defining ‘biological’ sex, how these measures would interact with the Equality Act’s protection for people who are ‘percieved’ to hold protected characteristics.

“This move risks opening yet another chapter in a manufactured culture war that will see little benefit to women — cis and trans alike.”

A U.K. government spokesman said: “We are committed to protecting women’s rights and the Minister for Women and Equalities regularly seeks advice from the independent equality regulator as part of her role." The advice would be considered "in the usual way,” they said.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Arab Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Israel Offers $5 Million for Each Gaza Hostage Freed
Israeli Strike Severely Disrupts Iran's Missile Production, Reports Saudi News
Blinken Sees Opportunity in Hamas Leader's Death
Israel Eliminates Successor of Hezbollah Leader Hassan Nasrallah
Global Unrest: Kenyan Political Tensions, India's Air Quality Crisis, Uganda's Opposition Trials, and Gaza's Humanitarian Plea Amid Israeli Offensive
Israeli Airstrike Targets Hezbollah's Financial Resources
Global Tensions and Cultural Engagement: North Korea's Alleged Troop Support for Russia, King Charles' Visit to Australia, and More
Iran Warns Biden on Israel Support Amid Rising Regional Tensions as Arab American Voters Poised to Sway 2024 Election
Regional Turmoil: Railway Safety Protests in Egypt, Humanitarian Crisis in Gaza, and Rising Tensions with Hezbollah and Iran
Global Tensions and Humanitarian Missions: WHO's Evacuation Efforts in Gaza Amid Rising Conflict Concerns
Global Tensions and Challenges: US Defense Moves, Rising Polio Cases, and Calls for Climate Leadership
UN Experts Warn of Complicity in War Crimes Supporting Israeli Occupation; Global Leaders Grapple with Geopolitical Crises
Global Crisis Update: Belgian War Crimes Investigation, Singapore Terror Plot Foiled, and Rising Middle East Tensions
Geopolitical Tensions Escalate: Lebanon-Iran Dispute, Macron's UN Defense, and North Korea’s Role in Ukraine
Biden Reinforces Transatlantic Ties in Germany as Middle East Tensions Escalate with Key Hamas Leader's Death and UN Peacekeepers Under Threat
Global Shifts: Fuel Crisis Drives Change in Nigeria, Diplomatic Overtures in South Asia, and Rising Tensions in Korea
Global Tensions Surge: German Warship Intercepts Drone, Jakarta Braces for Prabowo's Inauguration, and Israel Eliminates Hamas Leader
Xi Jinping Urges Troops to Prepare for Conflict Amid Taiwan Drills
Netanyahu Condemns Alleged Hezbollah Assassination Attempt
Israeli Leaflet Campaign in Gaza: A Critical Update
Espionage Tensions, Global Crises, and Calls for Humanitarian Action Define Geopolitical Landscape
Global Tensions Rise: New Sanctions on North Korea, Sudanese Refugee Crisis, and Shifts in U.S. and European Policies
Global Tensions and Political Shifts: Key Developments in Indonesia, U.S., Malaysia, China, Turkiye, and the Middle East
Southern Africa's Historical Drought Crisis Amid Global Tensions and Strategic Alliances
Biden Praises Israel's Military Action Against Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar
Yahya Sinwar’s Death Marks Pivotal Moment in Gaza War
Global Conflicts Escalate: World Bank Warns of $20 Billion Damages in Gaza, U.S. and International Tensions Rise
Hezbollah Deputy Chief Calls for Ceasefire Amidst Escalating Conflict with Israel
US Warns Israel of Potential Aid Cuts Over Gaza Assistance Delays
Meta Faces Legal Battle Over Teen Social Media Addiction
U.S. Criticizes Israel's Tactics in Beirut Amidst Humanitarian Concerns; Italy Opens Controversial Migrant Hub
Amid Israel-Hezbollah Tensions, France Evacuates Citizens; Global Leaders Urge De-escalation and Aid Efforts
Macron Urges Netanyahu to Honor UN Resolutions Amid Rising Tensions; Global Protests and Diplomatic Summits Highlight Complex Geopolitical Climate
Escalating Tensions: Israel's Planned Retaliation Against Iran Amid Global Geopolitical Shifts
Rising Tensions in Lebanon and Israel: Sectarian Strains and Military Moves Amid Humanitarian Efforts
Global Tensions and Political Shifts: UN Concerns in Tunisia, Italian Troop Security, Afghan Resettlement, and Strategic Alliances Forming
President of Venezuela Nicolás Maduro: "Long live Venezuela, long live Palestine, long live Lebanon. May their fights for freedom and dignity live on!
Regional Tensions Escalate: Iran and Israel Clash, U.S.-Philippines Drills Stir Southeast Asia, and Singapore Faces Legacy Dispute
Russia's Call for a BRICS Financial System Alternative
Israel Vows to Limit Retaliatory Strike on Iran to Military Facilities
Rising Geopolitical Tensions: UN Highlights Lebanese Child Displacement as U.S. Faces Shifts in Middle Eastern Alliances
Hezbollah's Drone Strikes Intensify Israeli-Lebanon Tensions, Prompting Global Security Concerns
International Tensions Escalate: Sweden's Qur'an Burning Trial, China's Diplomatic Moves in the Middle East, and Global Protests
Middle East Tensions, Nile River Pact Disputes, and Global Health Initiatives Highlight Complex International Challenges
Tensions Soar Globally: London Murder Trial, Middle East Conflicts, and UK's Landmark Anti-Zionism Ruling
Netanyahu Urges UN to Relocate Lebanon Peacekeepers Amid Escalating Tensions
EU Sanctions Iran for Arming Russia Amid Ukraine War; Global Tensions Escalate
Ukraine Strikes Deep in Russia; EU Denounces Israeli Attacks on UN Peacekeepers; Archaeologists Uncover Secrets of Petra's Hidden Tomb
Escalating Middle East Tensions and Global Shifts: Key Developments from Gaza to Southeast Asia and Europe
Global Tensions Surge: Iran's Missile Strikes, U.S. Security Concerns, and Regional Conflicts Intensify
×