Arab Press

بالشعب و للشعب
Tuesday, Sep 17, 2024

Will a Russian diamond ban be effective?

Will a Russian diamond ban be effective?

The UK has announced a ban on Russian diamonds as it tightens sanctions over Russia's war in Ukraine.

Countries in the G7 bloc also want to be able to trace the gemstones to block Russian exports as they try to limit cash flowing into Russia's war chest.

But how effective will these schemes be, and could there be unintended consequences?


How important are Russian diamond exports?


Russia's diamond trade, worth about $4bn (£3.2bn) per year, makes up a small proportion of its overall exports.

Before the invasion of Ukraine, Russia's total exports reached $489.8bn in 2021, according to the central bank, with oil and gas making up $240.7bn of that.

Nevertheless, Russia is the world's biggest diamond exporter by volume, followed by African countries.

A state-owned company called Alrosa dominates Russian diamond mining - and it mined almost a third of the world's diamonds in 2021.

Profits from Alrosa do flow into the Kremlin war chest, according to Hans Merket, a researcher with the International Peace Information Service - but it is nowhere near as important as oil and gas.



Why does the G7 want to track Russian diamonds?


Western countries want to cut off this revenue stream as part of efforts to hamper Russia's war.

However, the world's diamond trade is complex, and lacks transparency.

Diamonds can change hands 20 to 30 times between mine and market, Mr Merket said.

Typically the gemstones pass through the main global hubs of Antwerp, Dubai, Mumbai and Ramat Gan, which is near Tel Aviv.

Traders grade the stones for carat (weight), colour, clarity and cut - with different traders looking for different attributes.

They then take the remaining gemstones, mix them up, and sell them on - and the process is repeated.

Traders and firms jealously guard where they source their diamonds - it's their "secret sauce", according to Tobias Kormind, managing director of online jeweller 77 Diamonds.

But the major industry players could restrict the trade of Russian diamonds if they pulled together, he said.


How could the flow of Russian diamonds be restricted?


The US has already brought in sanctions to try to ban Russian diamond exports.

However, there is a "massive loophole" here, Mr Kormind said.

The restrictions apply to rough diamonds - but once they have been cut and polished, the country of origin no longer matters.

People in G7 countries buy about 70% of the world's diamonds - so a G7 ban could have an effect, if the diamonds can be traced, Mr Merket said.

However, a G7 ban would mean diamonds are likely to flow to other markets in China and India, Mr Kormind said.

Tracing the diamonds would make restricting that flow easier.


How could diamonds be traced?


There is already a scheme to try to restrict "blood diamonds" used to fuel conflict, called the Kimberley Process, where states certify that diamonds are "conflict free".

However, this does not allow the diamonds to be traced to the country of origin.

Mr Merket said the simplest way of tracing diamonds would be to extend this process to include documentation of where the stones come from.

There are also technologies that mark stones, and one is being developed that can scan them to check their geographical origin.


What effects would a ban have?


The majority of Russian diamonds end up in India, where there is a major cutting and polishing centre in Surat.

Smaller diamond businesses in the city have already suffered, in part due to the US ban.

In Africa, local mining operations benefitted after US sanctions hit Russian exports. However, many African mining producers are not ready to feed into a traceability scheme, Mr Merket said, and could be excluded if one is brought in.

In Angola, Russia's Alrosa has a significant stake in mining, and tightening sanctions could hit local firms.

For Europe, traceability needs to be "watertight, scientific, [and] international", said Tom Neys, head of media relations at the Antwerp World Diamond Centre.

If not, Europe risks losing $40bn in trade annually to places that don't have the frameworks to deal with money laundering and terrorism, he said.

He added that UK sanctions "will have no impact on the sale of Russian diamonds" because the UK represents less than 1% of the global diamond trade.

A UK government spokesperson said it would work with key partners to help restrict the Russian diamond trade, "including through tracing technologies".

Newsletter

Related Articles

Arab Press
0:00
0:00
Close
UN Debates Resolution on Israeli Occupation, Houthi-US Controversy, and Global Tensions Escalate
Zimbabwe Culls Elephants Amid Drought, as Mali, Papua New Guinea, and Gaza Grapple with Crises
Hamas Leader Yahya Sinwar Discusses Extended Conflict Preparedness
Israel Expands Gaza War Objectives Amid U.S. Plot Unveiling, UK Fiscal Plans, and Climate Change Warnings
Nation in Turmoil: Key Moments from Libya, Niger, Gaza, and a U.S. Assassination Plot
Palestinian President's Madrid Visit Marks Key Diplomatic Move Amid Regional Crises and Global Tensions
**Global Affairs Roundup: Key Diplomatic Updates from Egypt, Spain, Iran, and International Security Concerns**
Global Turmoil: Philippines Stands Firm in South China Sea, Nigeria Faces Floods, Russia Evacuates Border, Polio Threats in Afghanistan, UN Warns Israel, and Netanyahu Mulls Cabinet Shakeup
Iran's President Pledges Reforms on Morality Police and Internet Restrictions
UN Chief Criticizes Israel's Collective Punishment of Palestinians
Polio Vaccination Campaign Achieves 90% Coverage in Gaza Amid Conflict
Bail Granted to PTI Lawmakers Amidst Political Crackdown; Global Tensions Rise with Drone Downing and Middle East Conflict
Indian Police Detain Striking Workers at Samsung Plant Amid Labor Unrest in Tamil Nadu
New Biometric Passports Support Sahel States Unification Amidst Jihadist Turmoil
Hamas Claims Strong Capability to Continue Gaza War
Houthis Launch First Ballistic Missile Strike on Israel
Hamas Aims for Joint Rule in Gaza Amid Conflict; Global Turmoil and Hope in 2024
Tokyo Student Shaves Head in Solidarity with Palestinians amid Global Tensions
Israel Vows Retaliation Over Yemen Missile, Philippines Named Top Disaster Risk for 2024, and Global Geopolitical Tensions Rise
Iranian President to Attend BRICS Summit Amid Rising Tensions, Venezuela Arrests Foreign Nationals, and the Passing of Lebanese Novelist Elias Khoury
Global Shifts: Yemeni Missile Strikes Israel, China Adjusts Retirement Age, NATO Supports Ukraine, and Europe Battles Storm Boris
Nigerian Troops Rescue 13 Hostages; G7 Condemns Iran’s Missile Exports; Global Events Highlight Tensions and Struggles
Iran Denies Arms Export Allegations as Tensions Rise with Western Nations; Israeli Protests Demand Hostage Release
Global Crises: Train Tragedy in Egypt, Escalation in Israel-Hezbollah Conflict, and Deadly Airstrike in Gaza Amid Rising Tensions
Turkish Authorities Arrest Daesh Militant Suspected in Deadly Istanbul Church Attack; Global Political and Security Developments Unfold
Modi Declares 'Terrorism on its Last Legs' Amid Global Turmoil: Key Updates from Kashmir to Ukraine
Global Tensions Rise: North Korea-Russia Alliance Strengthens, Iran Launches Satellite Amid Middle East Strife, and EU Salvages Greek Tanker Attacked by Houthis
Global News Roundup: Mpox in Morocco, German Naval Passage Sparks Tension, Congo’s Death Sentences, Iran’s Hijab Defiance, Fujimori’s Legacy, and Myanmar’s Plea for Aid
Swift Evacuations in Springfield Amid False Bomb Threats, South Africa Proceeds with Genocide Case Against Israel, Strikes and Political Tensions in U.S. and Beyond
Turkiye Mourns Murder of Young Girl; Global Headlines Include Nigerian Flood Crisis, Tunisian Arrests, Iraq and Gaza Strife, and Ukraine Diplomacy
Escalating Conflicts in the West Bank, Lebanon, and Ukraine: A Global Perspective on Violence and Political Tensions
UK Introduces £10 Electronic Travel Authorization Amid Global Turmoil: Zelensky's Peace Plan, Middle East Tensions, and Argentina's Aviation Strike
Taliban Bans MMA, WHO Approves First Mpox Vaccine, UK's Largest Child Abuse Investigation Yields Convictions, Dutch Migration Controls Tighten, NATO Condemns Russian Missile Strike, and London's Migration Museum Celebrates Immigrant Contributions
Iran's Repression of Women Intensifies, Global Protests, and High-Stakes Diplomatic Efforts Mark A Day of Geopolitical Turmoil
Global Headlines: Quiboloy's Plea, Taiwan's F-16V Arrival, Hezbollah-Israel Clashes, Zambada's U.S. Arraignment, German Naval Movement, Morocco Flooding
Typhoon Yagi Devastates Southeast Asia while Global Tensions Rise: A Rundown of Major Events
Global Unrest: Israeli Strike Kills Child, Russia Expels British Diplomats, Sweden's Migration Policy, and More
PETA Condemns Real Bearskin Caps at Buckingham Palace, Offers Faux Alternatives Amid Soaring Costs and Global Turmoil
Biden Marks 30 Years of Violence Against Women Act; Global and Domestic Turmoil Heighten Tensions
Israel's Elite Unit 8200 Chief Resigns Amid Post-Hamas Attack Turmoil, Global Political Updates Follow
UN Struggles to Resolve Libya’s Central Bank Crisis Amid Broader Regional Turmoil; Salman Rushdie's Memoir Nominated for National Book Awards
Russian Attack on Red Cross Vehicles in Ukraine Highlights Humanitarian Risks; Notre Dame's Reopening Offers Glimmer of Hope Amid Global Crises
Global Outcry Follows Deadly Israeli Airstrike on Gaza School Amid Escalating Regional Conflicts and Cultural Looting
Turkiye Calls for UN Inquiry into Activist's Death Amidst Middle East Tensions
Global Justice, Economic Reforms, and War: Key Issues Captivating the World
Turkiye Condemns US-Cyprus Defense Pact Amid Escalating Global Tensions and Conflicts
Haitian Immigrants Boost Springfield’s Economy Amid Misinformation and Unity Efforts
International Outcry Over Shooting of Turkish-American Activist; Global Leaders Demand Accountability
Iranian President Criticizes Western Support for Israel in First International Trip to Baghdad Amid Tensions
Iran Denies Missile Deliveries to Russia Amid New Sanctions
×