Arab Press

بالشعب و للشعب
Wednesday, Dec 11, 2024

Washington Is Determined To Govern Artificial Intelligence, But How?

Washington Is Determined To Govern Artificial Intelligence, But How?

Interviews with a US senator, congressional staffers, AI companies and interest groups show there are a number of options under discussion.
US lawmakers are grappling with what guardrails to put around burgeoning artificial intelligence, but months after ChatGPT got Washington's attention, consensus is far from certain.

Interviews with a US senator, congressional staffers, AI companies and interest groups show there are a number of options under discussion.

Some proposals focus on AI that may put people's lives or livelihoods at risk, like in medicine and finance. Other possibilities include rules to ensure AI isn't used to discriminate or violate someone's civil rights.

Another debate is whether to regulate the developer of AI or the company that uses it to interact with consumers. And OpenAI, the startup behind the chatbot sensation ChatGPT, has discussed a standalone AI regulator.

It's uncertain which approaches will win out, but some in the business community, including IBM and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, favor the approach that only regulates critical areas like medical diagnoses, which they call a risk-based approach.

If Congress decides new laws are necessary, the US Chamber's AI Commission advocates that "risk be determined by impact to individuals," said Jordan Crenshaw of the Chamber's Technology Engagement Center. "A video recommendation may not pose as high of a risk as decisions made about health or finances."

Surging popularity of so-called generative AI, which uses data to create new content like ChatGPT's human-sounding prose, has sparked concern the fast-evolving technology could encourage cheating on exams, fuel misinformation and lead to a new generation of scams.

The AI hype has led to a flurry of meetings, including a White House visit this month by the CEOs of OpenAI, its backer Microsoft Corp, and Alphabet Inc. President Joe Biden met with the CEOs.

Congress is similarly engaged, say congressional aides and tech experts.

"Staff broadly across the House and the Senate have basically woken up and are all being asked to get their arms around this," said Jack Clark, co-founder of high-profile AI startup Anthropic, whose CEO also attended the White House meeting. "People want to get ahead of AI, partly because they feel like they didn't get ahead of social media."

As lawmakers get up to speed, Big Tech's main priority is to push against "premature overreaction," said Adam Kovacevich, head of the pro-tech Chamber of Progress.

And while lawmakers like Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer are determined to tackle AI issues in a bipartisan way, the fact is Congress is polarized, a Presidential election is next year, and lawmakers are addressing other big issues, like raising the debt ceiling.

Schumer's proposed plan requires independent experts to test new AI technologies prior to their release. It also calls for transparency and providing the government with data it needs to avert harm.

Government Micromanagement

The risk-based approach means AI used to diagnose cancer, for example, would be scrutinized by the Food and Drug Administration, while AI for entertainment would not be regulated. The European Union has moved toward passing similar rules.

But the focus on risks seems insufficient to Democratic Senator Michael Bennet, who introduced a bill calling for a government AI task force. He said he advocates for a "values-based approach" to prioritize privacy, civil liberties and rights.

Risk-based rules may be too rigid and fail to pick up dangers like AI's use to recommend videos that promote white supremacy, a Bennet aide added.

Legislators have also discussed how best to ensure AI is not used to racially discriminate, perhaps in deciding who gets a low-interest mortgage, according to a person following congressional discussions who is not authorized to speak to reporters.

At OpenAI, staff have contemplated broader oversight.

Cullen O'Keefe, an OpenAI research scientist, proposed in an April talk at Stanford University the creation of an agency that would mandate that companies obtain licenses before training powerful AI models or operating the data centers that facilitate them. The agency, O'Keefe said, could be called the Office for AI Safety and Infrastructure Security, or OASIS.

Asked about the proposal, Mira Murati, OpenAI's chief technology officer, said a trustworthy body could "hold developers accountable" to safety standards. But more important than the mechanics was agreement "on what are the standards, what are the risks that you're trying to mitigate."

The last major regulator to be created was the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which was set up after the 2007-2008 financial crisis.

Some Republicans may balk at any AI regulation.

"We should be careful that AI regulatory proposals don't become the mechanism for government micromanagement of computer code like search engines and algorithms," a Senate Republican aide told Reuters.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Arab Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Russia’s Safe Haven: Bashar al-Assad Transferred Amid International Scrutiny
Israel's Delicate Balancing Act in Syrian Turmoil
Syrian Chemical Arsenal: A Looming Global Threat in Assad's Wake
Qatar's Democratic Dilemma: A Referendum on Representation
The Obsession That Could Divide: GB News and Its Singular Focus on UK Muslims
Anatomy of Regime Change: The Key Players in Syria's Tumultuous Fall
Syria After Assad: A Pyrrhic Victory with Uncertain Horizons
The Day After Assad: Can Syria Steer Clear of the Libyan Pitfall?
UAE Accelerates Quantum Computing Investment: A Leap into the Future
Geopolitical Chess: Trump's Reflections on Russia's Waned Syrian Influence
Iranian Embassy in Damascus Attacked Amidst Rising Tensions
A New Dawn in Syria: The Flag That Signals Change
Assad's Departure Signals New Epoch for Syria
Bridging Continents: The EU-GCC Summit's Strategic Dance
The Brussels Nexus: Balancing Energy, Economy, and Human Rights at the EU-GCC Summit
Dubai Ride 2024 Transforms Sheikh Zayed Road into Cycling Haven
UAE's Bold Leap into Space: Navigating Innovation and Ambition
UAE's Health Initiatives Pave the Way for Medical Breakthroughs and Global Partnerships
Piercing the Cosmic Veil: Abu Dhabi's Astronomical Breakthrough
Benralizumab: A Potential Milestone in Asthma Treatment
Navigating the Cosmos: UAE's Leap Toward Space Supremacy
Border Closures Echo Through the Middle East: The Syrian Conflict's New Chapter
Iran Releases Nobel Laureate Narges Mohammadi Amidst Global Appeals
UAE's Celestial Events and Scientific Milestones Take Center Stage
Narges Mohammadi: A Temporary Reprieve in the Struggle for Freedom
Syria's Strategic Chokehold: The Tumultuous Fate of Homs
Syrian Rebels' Swift Offensive Threatens Assad's Regime
Aleppo's Revitalized Front: A Crucible for Russia's Middle Eastern Ambitions
Global Tensions Rise Amid Accusations, Advances, and Diplomatic Shifts
A Temporary Release: The Fragile Freedom of Iran's Narges Mohammadi
Syrian Rebels Make Major Gains in Aleppo
UK Intelligence Chief Warns: Iran's Nuclear Ambitions Pose Global Threat
Hezbollah Chief Declares 'Great Victory' Against Israel
Hamas Delegation Engages in Gaza Ceasefire Talks in Egypt
Rebel Advances Lead to Aleppo Airport Closure
France's Delicate Position on Netanyahu's ICC Arrest Warrant
Global Tensions Mount: Israel-Hezbollah Ceasefire Strained, International Calls for Free Expression, and Strategic Military Shifts
La Niña Devastates Indonesia, Military Corruption Unraveling in China, and Rising Tensions in Middle East: Global Briefing
Walmart Drops Diversity Initiatives Amid Broader Conservative Backlash; Global Drug Crackdown and More News Highlights
Global Tensions and Legal Battles: Mexican Trade Disputes, British Investigations, and India's Energy Challenges
Elon Musk's Call to Abolish CFPB, Trump's Controversial Appointments, and Global Tensions: Key Developments in Politics and Security
Ceasefire in Lebanon Tested Amidst U.S. Arms Sale to Israel and Ongoing Gaza Conflict
US and France Broker Ceasefire Between Israel and Hezbollah as Regional Tensions Simmer
Tragedy at Sea: Egyptian Rescue Mission Unfolds Amidst Global Tensions and Legal Battles
Ukraine Seeks South Korean Weapons Aid Amid Russian Conflict; Global Tensions and Defense Shifts Unfold
Israeli Finance Minister Advocates Halving Gaza's Population
Israel and Lebanon Reach Ceasefire Agreement
UN Investigates Exploitation in Chad Refugee Camps as Middle Eastern and US Tensions Unfold
Historic Opportunity for Turkish-Kurdish Peace Talks as Global Tensions Rise
UK Campaigners Seek High Court Injunction on F-35 Parts to Israel Amid Rising Middle East Tensions
×