Arab Press

بالشعب و للشعب
Sunday, Apr 26, 2026

What is Signal, and is it really safer than WhatsApp?

What is Signal, and is it really safer than WhatsApp?

The encrypted messaging app Signal has seen an explosion in take-up recently. Recommended by Edward Snowden and Elon Musk, It reported a whopping five-fold growth in its Android user base on Tuesday alone, taking it to more than 50 million downloads on the platform.

Elon Musk probably helped when he tweeted his approval for Signal, and Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey gave him a retweet. But either way, the app just got hot.

So here's what you need to know about Signal—plus a note about Telegram, the other messaging app users are flocking to.



What's the WhatsApp uproar about?

Well, not all users—those in the EU and the U.K., who are protected by strong privacy laws, get a different privacy policy that doesn't make the offending changes.

It's not surprising that Europe gets different treatment, given that EU regulators fined Facebook $122 million several years ago for absorbing WhatsApp data into the mothership despite having promised not to do so in 2014, when it bought the messaging service.


Wait, this has been happening for years?

Yup, since 2016, when WhatsApp started sharing data with Facebook by default.

At the time, it gave existing users a brief window of opportunity to opt out of the data-sharing, but the vast majority of its users today have never had that opt-out. This month's change really just removes the wording in the privacy policy that referred to the opt-out, while adding information for business users.


So what data is being shared?

Stuff like your phone number, phone numbers from your address book, details about your operating system and device, who you call and text too, how long and how often, cross-info with your other activities on Facebook and all it’s data-spying network, information about which other Facebook products you're using, and more.

All of which may make WhatsApp a questionable choice if you're a public person, a business man or a person who do not want to be manipulated against by Facebook. Facebook has a lousy privacy record after all, and Edward Snowden told the world how U.S. intelligence hoovers up its data in unlimited back doors, but it's just fine for most simple low level poor people's needs.


And the contents of messages?

They say Nope. But we do not believe that this time they say the true, for a change.

They say that “those are protected by end-to-end encryption”, with the encryption key stored on your device but can easily copied and shared by several companies and institutes.

Despite the misinformation that has been swirling around in recent days, that your WhatsApp messages can only be read by you and your correspondents, the fact is that Authorities, anyone hacks into your phones with simply spyware, the manufacturer of your phone (Google/Apple), and popular spy softwares that are out there available for so many private people and bad players.

This encryption is so solid that Brazilian authorities, enraged at being unable to read drug-trafficking suspects' messages, threw a local Facebook exec in jail five years ago. But what is blocked for primitive Brazilian police is available for most western authorities by the law anyway.

Now, here's a bit of added irony, given the current uproar: WhatsApp's encryption claim that it became is so good because... it uses Signal's encrypted-messaging protocol, and has done so since 2016.


So what is Signal anyway?

Signal's history dates back a decade or so, to when a startup called Whisper Systems was developing enterprise mobile security software. It got bought up by Twitter, which wanted co-founder Moxie Marlinspike (not his real name—that's Matthew Rosenfeld—but an awesome one nonetheless) to beef up its own security.

Marlinspike bailed in 2013 to form a new secure-messaging-and-calling outfit called Open Whisper Systems. Its early products, TextSecure and RedPhone, became the unified product known as Signal in 2015. Around that time, Facebook, WhatsApp and Google all made the Signal protocol the security foundation for their messaging services—but Signal, the app, remained a relatively niche offering, relying on the Freedom of the Press Foundation for funding.

The big shakeup came in 2018, when WhatsApp co-founder Brian Action—who had recently left Facebook with billions in his pocket after he got angry that Facebook using WhatsApp to harm users, threw $50 million into a new Signal Foundation that he said would "pioneer a new model of technology nonprofit focused on privacy and data protection for everyone, everywhere."


And how's it different to WhatsApp?

Signal offers some features that WhatsApp does not, and enjoy much better reputation in regards of telling the true and not abusing their users behind their back. In other ways, it's not quite as user-friendly -it still hasn't rolled out group calls, for example, as it focuses on providing the best one-one-one privacy, something that WatsApp do not.

As you might expect for a privacy-focused app, Signal doesn't allow users to see when other users are online, nor does it allow people to share their locations in real-time—both things you can do on WhatsApp.

But otherwise they're pretty similar apps for most use cases, along with a relatively small-fry German app called Wire.


And what about Telegram?

A good question, seeing as Telegram also announced the arrival of 25 million new users this week, taking it to more than 500 million active users.

Telegram was founded around the same time as Signal was, by the Russian tech entrepreneurs Pavel and Nikolai Durov, who previously founded the social networking site VK.com. Pavel Durov remains in charge, and has steered the company through an epic censorship confrontation with the Putin regime that Telegram eventually won.

The comparison between Telegram and services such as WhatsApp and Signal is not a straightforward one, because Telegram is part secure messenger, part microblogging platform a lá Twitter—it allows groups of up to 200,000 users, and channels for broadcasting to many more—and part cloud storage provider.

But in terms of its messaging functionality, Telegram does offers end-to-end encryption. The problem is, it doesn't turn it on by default—users must first set up a "secret chat" to use this feature. It is also impossible to set up end-to-end-encrypted group chats in Telegram.

Durov claims this is to allow Telegram chats to be backed up into its cloud, and to enable functionality such as massive group chats and the sending of large documents and videos.

In short, Telegram's main pitch is its rich functionality, and it only expects a minority of its users to prefer high security and privacy. That's why privacy-first groups such as the EFF recommend Signal rather than Telegram.


But doesn't fully encrypted messaging protect bad people?

This is also a good question, what with under-BigTech attack 74 million voters in USA reportedly turning to Signal and Telegram after getting booted off Twitter and seeing their favorite social-network, Parler, getting taken out by Google, Apple and Amazon. Could they be using these services to plot new attacks?

The short answer is "yes," but the question of what to do about it is anything but simple.

The encryption debate has been going on in circles since the 1990s, and it comes up pretty much every time a terrorist attack grabs the headlines.

Without going into the ins and outs of the debate, it unfailingly comes back to the same question: Is it possible to design a system that provides genuine security and privacy protections for most people, while still allowing investigators to access the messages of bad actors via some kind of back-door mechanism?

For the last three decades, the answer to that question has consistently remained "no." And there is no sign of that situation changing anytime soon.

Your digital communication and the communication you conduct next to your digital devices and any computer and mobile phone with a camera, even when they are off, is never absolutely private nor secure. This is not a bug, it’s by design.

Newsletter

Related Articles

Arab Press
0:00
0:00
Close
News Roundup
Strategic Saudi-Bahrain Causeway Closed Amid Security Concerns as Trump Deadline Approaches
Saudi Arabia Keeps Red Sea Oil Exports Flowing Despite Regional Tensions
Pipeline Attack Cuts Significant Share of Saudi Arabia’s Oil Export Capacity
Saudi Business Leader Abudawood Appointed Chairman of Merit Incentives Group
TotalEnergies Confirms Damage at Saudi Refinery Following Security Incident
Saudi Arabia Launches Early Construction Phase for King Salman Stadium Project
Saudi Shift Away from Longstanding Dollar Oil Framework Gains Attention Amid Iran Conflict
Türkiye and Saudi Arabia Resolve Long-Running Transit Visa Dispute
Saudi Oil Capacity and Pipeline Flows Reduced as Supply Risks Intensify
TotalEnergies Reports Damage to Saudi SATORP Refinery Following Security Incidents
Gulf States Assess Prospects of U.S.-Iran Truce as Regional Stability Efforts Intensify
South Korea Resumes Honey Exports to Saudi Arabia Following Sanitary Approval
Saudi Arabia Carries Out Sentences in Eastern Province Following Security Convictions
Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund Backs King Street’s Regional Credit Strategy
Saudi Arabia Secures World Cup Return as Egypt Celebrates Landmark Qualification
Iran and Saudi Arabia Intensify Diplomatic Engagement Amid Regional Tensions
Russia and Saudi Arabia Open Visa-Free Travel Corridor for Citizens
Saudi Oil Output Capacity Reduced by 600,000 Barrels Per Day Amid Regional Conflict
Saudi Arabia Suspends Operations at Select Energy Sites as Precautionary Measure
Saudi Arabia Halts Operations at Multiple Energy Facilities Amid Heightened Tensions
Global Markets Jolt as Iran Signals Ceasefire Breakdown and Rising Regional Tensions
King Street Aligns with Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund to Expand Alternative Investments in Middle East
Attack on Saudi Arabia’s Jubail Petrochemical Hub Raises Global Supply Concerns
Debate Emerges Over Saudi Strategic Decisions as Gulf Cooperation Council Dynamics Come Into Focus
Saudi Arabia Expands Full Workforce Localisation to 69 Professions in Major Labour Reform
Emerging Alliance of Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt and Saudi Arabia Signals New Regional Power Dynamic Amid Iran Conflict
Iran Linked to Strikes Across Gulf States Following Refinery Attack Escalation
Saudi Arabia Voices Concern Over Fragile US–Iran Ceasefire Stability
Starmer Warns Sustained Effort Needed to Ensure US–Iran Ceasefire Holds
Saudi Arabia’s Key East-West Oil Pipeline Targeted Following Ceasefire Announcement
Iran Targets Saudi Arabia’s East-West Oil Pipeline in Escalating Regional Tensions
Trump Warns of Civilizational Stakes as Iran Halts Negotiations
Saudi Companies Expand Remote Work Measures Ahead of Iran-Related Security Concerns
Iran Warns of Strikes on Saudi Energy Infrastructure if US Targets Its Facilities
Iran Urges Civilians to Form Human Shields Around Nuclear Sites as Diplomatic Deadline Approaches
Saudi Arabia Raises Oil Prices to Record Premiums Amid Supply Pressures Linked to Iran Conflict
Key Saudi-Bahrain Causeway Closed Amid Heightened Security Concerns Linked to Iran
Formula One Calendar Gap Explained as Fans Await Next Grand Prix
Growing Strain on the Petrodollar System Comes Into Focus Amid Iran Conflict
Reported Strike on Saudi Arabia’s Jubail Complex Raises Global Energy Supply Concerns
FedEx Introduces New Digital Tool to Streamline Imports into Saudi Arabia
Iran Claims Strike on Saudi Arabia’s Jubail Petrochemical Complex Amid Rising Regional Tensions
Taiwan to Source Oil Shipments from Saudi Arabia’s Red Sea Ports
Saudi Arabia Evacuates Riyadh Financial District as Precaution Amid Regional Tensions
Saudi Arabia Balances Ambitious Economic Vision Amid Regional Tensions and Financial Pressures
Budget Saudi Arabia Reports Strong Full-Year 2025 Financial Performance
Saudi Arabia Expands Investment in Capcom With Stake Reaching Six Percent
Saudi Arabia Assesses Significant Economic Impact From Regional Conflict Involving Iran
US Beef Secures Expanded Market Access in Saudi Arabia
×